Wednesday, October 26, 2005

the joys of self pity

As per usual, I have been thinking very hard this morning (when your job fosters escapist feelings, what else is there to do?) and the topic that wouldn't leave my well-developed mind was this: why do so many people love sad songs? What is the attraction of depressing music? I am no exception to this. I love a funereal rock ballad just as much as the next guy, but I want to know the reason for this. Breakup songs, she-cheated-on-me-and-now-I-hate-her songs, and other similarly themed ditties often find their way into my 'best-of' lists. I realized that it comes down to humankind's natural tendency toward self-pity. Most of us are good at feeling sorry for ourselves, especially in the romance department when things go sour. When I broke up with one of my girlfriends five years ago, I would lie in my darkened bedroom and listen to "Wild Horses" (the Stones) and "Black" (Pearl Jam) over and over again (piece of advice: the version of "Black" from Live on Two Legs is even more gut-wrenching than the original on Ten, especially Mike McCready's song ending solo, so if you really want some assistance climbing into the emotional abyss, this is the song for you). I knew as I repeated this destructive behaviour that I was not making things any better for myself, but I just couldn't stop. The funny thing is, I know that I am not alone in this. This is not an isolated case. There are thousands and thousands of people who are exactly like me and in a way, we don't really want to stop. We feeling sorry for ourselves for some stupid reason. I think that I am beginning to grow out of this now (it could help that I am engaged), but I STILL enjoy those depressing tales of lost love. I have no solutions to this issue, but it makes me laugh to write about it and so I did. As Elton John so eloquently put it: "Sad songs say so much..."

2 comments:

bethy said...

I think it's hard for me to listen to really upbeat songs when I'm feeling lousy because it's like a slap in the face... like, "look, isn't life wonderful? why can't you just be happy?" when I'm in the middle of the painful reality that it's not that simple. Ben Harper has written some of the best self-pity songs ever, in my opinion.

AJ Renton said...

I'd have to add 'Boyz II Men' as producers of some of the best 'sad/breakup' songs out there. I know Matty B would agree. i've seen him slow-dance the night away to those harmonizing geniuses many a times.